‹ Diet

Longevity · Diet deep dive

Coffee: Health Food or a Habit to Cut?

In one sentence: Coffee went from suspected carcinogen to one of the most reassuring drinks in nutrition research, with moderate drinkers consistently living longer, but most of that evidence is observational, and there are a few groups who should be more careful.

The king, the twins and the teapot

There's a story told in Sweden about King Gustav III, who ruled in the late 1700s. Convinced that coffee was a dangerous poison, he supposedly ordered an experiment on a pair of identical twins who had been sentenced to death. Their sentences were changed to life in prison, on one condition: one twin had to drink three pots of coffee every day, and the other three pots of tea. Two doctors were assigned to watch and record who died first.

As the story goes, both doctors died first. Then the king was assassinated. Years later, the tea-drinking twin died, and the coffee drinker outlived him.

Historians aren't sure it ever happened. But the story captures something true about coffee's reputation: for centuries, people have suspected it was bad for us, and the evidence has kept stubbornly refusing to cooperate.

How coffee conquered the world

Coffee has been controversial from the start. Legend says an Ethiopian goat herder named Kaldi noticed his goats dancing after eating coffee berries. That's almost certainly a myth too. What's better documented is that by the 1400s, Sufi monks in Yemen were drinking coffee to stay awake through night prayers.

From there it spread, and so did the suspicion. In 1511, the governor of Mecca briefly banned it. In 1675, King Charles II of England tried to shut down London's coffeehouses, which he saw as breeding grounds for gossip and rebellion. The ban collapsed within days.

Coffeehouses became known as "penny universities," where for the price of a cup you could hear the latest news and debate. Today, more than two billion cups are drunk around the world every day.

From suspect to staple

For much of the 20th century, coffee looked guilty. Early studies linked it to heart disease and cancer. In 1991, the World Health Organization's cancer agency classified it as "possibly carcinogenic," mainly because of bladder cancer data.

Then researchers noticed a problem. Back then, coffee drinkers smoked far more than non-drinkers. Once later studies properly accounted for smoking, most of the scary links faded away.

In 2016, the same cancer agency reviewed more than 1,000 studies and removed coffee from its "possibly carcinogenic" list, noting that coffee was actually linked with lower risk of some cancers. (It did flag drinking very hot beverages, above about 65°C or 149°F, as a probable cause of esophageal cancer. That's about temperature, not coffee.)

Today, coffee is one of the most studied parts of the human diet. Here's what all that research has found.

What's in your cup

  • Caffeine: An 8 oz (240 ml) cup of brewed coffee has roughly 80 to 100 mg on average, though it varies a lot. A large coffee shop brew can top 300 mg. A shot of espresso has about 60 to 75 mg.
  • Polyphenols: Coffee is one of the biggest sources of these plant compounds in many Western diets.
  • Cafestol and kahweol: Oily compounds that raise LDL cholesterol. Paper filters trap most of them.
  • Small amounts of minerals like potassium and magnesium.

Decaf keeps most of the polyphenols without the caffeine, which helps scientists figure out which part of coffee does what.

The big picture: more benefit than harm

In 2017, researchers published an "umbrella review" in the BMJ, a study of studies that pulled together more than 200 analyses of coffee and health 1. Their findings:

  • Coffee was linked with benefit more often than harm across a wide range of outcomes.
  • The biggest drop in risk of death from any cause came at about 3 to 4 cups a day, around 17% lower than non-drinkers.
  • Coffee drinkers had lower rates of heart disease, several cancers, type 2 diabetes, liver disease, gallstones, Parkinson's disease and depression.
  • The possible harms showed up in pregnancy (low birth weight, preterm birth and pregnancy loss) and a possible link with fractures in women.

For cancer specifically, a 2020 review found coffee was linked with lower risk of several cancers, most clearly liver and endometrial cancer, with no clear link to most others 2. An earlier analysis agreed that coffee wasn't linked with higher overall cancer risk 3.

Caffeine may even help a little with weight. Trials found it produced small reductions in weight and body fat 4. Small is the key word.

The catch: who drinks coffee?

Almost everything above comes from observational studies, and coffee has some special traps:

  • The "healthy drinker" effect. People who feel well tend to keep drinking coffee. People who get sick often cut back. That can make coffee look protective even if it isn't.
  • Lifestyle differences. Coffee drinkers differ from non-drinkers in many ways. Smoking was once the big one. Others may still be hiding.
  • What's a cup? It varies hugely between studies and countries.

Scientists have tried genetic studies to get around these problems, with mixed results. And there will probably never be a trial randomly assigning thousands of people to drink coffee or not for 30 years.

What we don't know: Whether coffee causes the lower risks, or whether coffee drinkers are healthier for other reasons. The consistency is encouraging. It isn't proof.

Myths, busted and confirmed

"Coffee dehydrates you" (busted)

In a 2014 study, 50 men who regularly drank coffee spent three days drinking four cups of coffee a day, and three days drinking the same amount of water. Researchers measured their hydration closely and found no difference 5. Regular drinkers adapt to caffeine's mild diuretic effect, and the water in the coffee more than makes up for it.

"Afternoon coffee won't affect my sleep" (busted)

Caffeine blocks adenosine, a chemical that builds up during the day and makes you sleepy. In most adults, about half the caffeine is still in your system around five hours later.

In a sleep lab study, 400 mg of caffeine taken six hours before bed still cut total sleep by more than an hour, and people didn't always notice 6. If you sleep poorly, a caffeine curfew in the early afternoon is one of the simplest fixes available.

"Coffee is bad for your heart" (mostly busted)

Caffeine can briefly raise blood pressure, especially in people who don't drink it often. Regular drinkers adapt. Large studies haven't found that moderate coffee raises the risk of irregular heart rhythm (atrial fibrillation), and some suggest lower risk. People with uncontrolled blood pressure or rhythm problems should still check with their doctor.

"Coffee raises cholesterol" (depends how you brew it)

Unfiltered coffee, like French press, boiled, Scandinavian-style or Turkish coffee, contains cafestol, which raises LDL. Paper-filtered drip coffee removes most of it. Espresso is in between. If your LDL is high, switching to filtered coffee is an easy win.

"Some people's genes make coffee risky" (unsettled)

People differ in how quickly they break down caffeine, thanks to variations in a liver enzyme called CYP1A2. Some research suggests "slow metabolizers" might not get the same benefits, or might face more risk with heavy drinking. It's intriguing but unsettled, and genetic testing for it isn't part of normal care.

How much is too much?

A large review of caffeine safety concluded 7:

  • Healthy adults: up to about 400 mg a day (about 4 cups of brewed coffee) isn't linked with significant health risks.
  • Pregnancy: many health authorities recommend staying at or below 200 mg a day.
  • Children and teens: about 2.5 mg per kg of body weight per day.

Plenty of people feel jittery, anxious or get palpitations at much lower doses. Your body's signals count.

Coffee and specific conditions

  • Type 2 diabetes: Regular and decaf coffee drinkers consistently show lower risk of developing it.
  • Liver disease: Coffee is linked with lower risk of fibrosis, cirrhosis and liver cancer, one of the most consistent findings in coffee research 1,2.
  • Reflux: Coffee triggers symptoms in some people but not others.
  • Anxiety: People with anxiety disorders may be more sensitive and often feel better with less.
  • Medications: Coffee can reduce absorption of thyroid medication if taken at the same time, and caffeine interacts with some other drugs. Pharmacists can advise on timing.

A bonus for athletes

Caffeine is one of the best-proven performance aids in sports science. A review of 21 analyses found it improves endurance, strength and power 8. The doses used in studies (about 3 to 6 mg per kg of body weight) are higher than one cup for most people.

Don't forget what's in it

Much of what people buy as "coffee" is closer to dessert. A large flavored latte or frappé can carry 300 to 500 calories and 40 to 60 grams of sugar. The research above is mostly about regular coffee, black or with a little milk.

What about tea and energy drinks?

Coffee isn't the only source of caffeine:

  • Black tea: about 40 to 50 mg per cup. Green tea: about 25 to 40 mg.
  • Cola: about 30 to 40 mg per can.
  • Energy drinks: from about 80 mg to more than 300 mg per can.

Tea also has encouraging observational links with heart health, with the same caveats as coffee. Energy drinks are a different story. They can deliver a lot of caffeine fast, often with plenty of sugar, and they're popular with teens. Mixing them with alcohol can mask how drunk someone feels.

The scorecard

Question What the evidence suggests Confidence
Is moderate coffee linked with longer life? Yes, consistently Moderate
Does coffee cause cancer? No; it's linked with lower risk of some Moderate
Does it dehydrate regular drinkers? No High
Does late caffeine hurt sleep? Yes High
Is up to 400 mg a day safe for healthy adults? Yes, for most Moderate to high

Common questions

Is decaf healthy too? Decaf shows some of the same links with lower disease risk, including for type 2 diabetes. It's a great option later in the day.

Does coffee stunt growth? No good evidence supports this old belief.

Is coffee on an empty stomach bad? Some people get heartburn. Without symptoms, there's no clear evidence of harm.

What about bones? Heavy intake has been linked with slightly higher fracture risk in women in some studies, but results are inconsistent. A splash of milk largely offsets caffeine's small effect on calcium.

Does milk cancel coffee's benefits? There's little evidence either way. Most coffee drinkers in the big studies added milk, so it doesn't seem to erase the associations.

Is cold brew different? It's usually less acidic, which some stomachs prefer. It can also be stronger, so check the caffeine.

The takeaway

Whether or not King Gustav's twins ever existed, the modern evidence tells a similar story: the coffee drinker usually doesn't come out worse, and often seems to come out ahead.

  • If you enjoy coffee and tolerate it well, there's no strong reason to quit.
  • Don't start drinking it just for your health. The evidence isn't strong enough for that.
  • Set a caffeine curfew if you sleep poorly.
  • Choose filtered coffee if your LDL is high.
  • Watch the sugar in fancy coffee drinks.
  • If you're pregnant or have heart rhythm problems, uncontrolled blood pressure or anxiety, ask your doctor what amount is right for you.

Coffee may never be proven to cause a longer life. But after centuries of suspicion, it's earned its place at the breakfast table.

References

  1. Poole R, et al. Coffee consumption and health: umbrella review of meta-analyses of multiple health outcomes. BMJ. 2017;359:j5024.

  2. Zhao LG, et al. Coffee drinking and cancer risk: an umbrella review of meta-analyses of observational studies. BMC Cancer. 2020;20(1):101. PubMed 32024485

  3. Wang A, et al. Coffee and cancer risk: a meta-analysis of prospective observational studies. Sci Rep. 2016;6:33711. PubMed 27665923

  4. Tabrizi R, et al. The effects of caffeine intake on weight loss: a systematic review and dose-response meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2019;59(16):2688-2696. PubMed 30335479

  5. Killer SC, Blannin AK, Jeukendrup AE. No evidence of dehydration with moderate daily coffee intake: a counterbalanced cross-over study in a free-living population. PLoS One. 2014;9(1):e84154. PubMed 24416202

  6. Drake C, et al. Caffeine effects on sleep taken 0, 3, or 6 hours before going to bed. J Clin Sleep Med. 2013;9(11):1195-1200. PubMed 24235903

  7. Wikoff D, et al. Systematic review of the potential adverse effects of caffeine consumption in healthy adults, pregnant women, adolescents, and children. Food Chem Toxicol. 2017;109(Pt 1):585-648. PubMed 28438661

  8. Grgic J, et al. Wake up and smell the coffee: caffeine supplementation and exercise performance, an umbrella review of 21 published meta-analyses. Br J Sports Med. 2020;54(11):681-688. PubMed 30926628

This article is for general education and isn't a substitute for personalized medical advice.