‹ Diet

Longevity · Diet deep dive

Artificial Sweeteners: Safe Swap or Hidden Risk?

In one sentence: In trials, swapping sugary drinks for diet ones leads to modest weight loss without raising blood sugar, but long-term observational studies tell a more worrying story, and untangling the two is the key to every sweetener headline you'll ever read.

Two chemists who forgot to wash their hands

In 1879, a chemist named Constantin Fahlberg was working late in a lab at Johns Hopkins University. When he sat down to dinner, he noticed his bread tasted strangely sweet. So did his hands. He'd forgotten to wash them after working with coal tar compounds. He went back to the lab, tasted his way through his equipment, and discovered saccharin, the first artificial sweetener.

Almost a century later, in 1965, a chemist named James Schlatter was working on an ulcer drug. Some of a compound spilled on his hand. Later, he licked his finger to pick up a piece of paper, and tasted something intensely sweet. That accident gave us aspartame.

Since then, sweeteners have gone from lab curiosities to everywhere: diet sodas, "sugar-free" yogurts, protein powders, chewing gum, and little colored packets on every café counter. For people trying to cut sugar, lose weight or manage diabetes, they look like a perfect solution.

And yet, every year or two, a new headline suggests otherwise. In 2023 alone:

  • The World Health Organization advised against using sweeteners for weight control.
  • The WHO's cancer agency classified aspartame as "possibly carcinogenic."
  • A lab study said a compound related to sucralose damages DNA.
  • A study linked erythritol, a popular sugar alcohol, to heart attacks and strokes.

So are sweeteners a smart swap or a hidden risk? The answer depends on which kind of evidence you're looking at.

Meet the sweeteners

Sweetener Familiar names Notes
Aspartame NutraSweet, Equal Common in diet sodas; breaks down with heat
Sucralose Splenda Heat-stable; used in baking
Saccharin Sweet'N Low The original
Acesulfame-K Sunett Often blended
Stevia Truvia, PureVia Purified plant extract
Monk fruit Various Plant-derived
Erythritol Often blended with stevia or monk fruit Sugar alcohol

These are very different chemicals. A finding about one doesn't automatically apply to the others.

Two kinds of evidence, two different stories

The whole sweetener debate makes sense once you understand one thing: trials and observational studies are telling different stories.

  • Randomized controlled trials assign people to use sweeteners or not, then measure what happens. They're the best way to show cause and effect, but they usually last weeks to a year or two.
  • Observational studies follow huge groups for many years. They can track cancer and heart attacks, but they can't easily separate the sweetener from the kind of person who uses it.

Let's hear both stories.

Story one: what the trials say

Weight

  • A 2016 review of human trials found that sweeteners reduced calorie intake and body weight compared with sugar, with no sign they increased appetite 1.
  • A 2014 analysis found trials produced modest weight loss, about 0.8 kg on average 2.
  • In a 2019 trial, 154 adults with overweight added drinks sweetened with saccharin, sucralose, aspartame, stevia or sugar every day for 12 weeks. The sugar group gained weight. The sucralose group lost a little, and the others stayed about the same 3.
  • In a one-year weight-loss program, people allowed to drink diet beverages lost more weight than people told to drink only water 4. The beverage industry funded this study, which is worth knowing, though its design was reasonable.

Blood sugar

An analysis of randomized trials found sweeteners didn't meaningfully raise blood glucose 5. In people with type 2 diabetes, three months of sucralose didn't affect blood sugar control 6.

The microbiome surprise

In 2014, a study in Nature reported that sweeteners changed the gut bacteria of mice and impaired how they handled sugar 7. The researchers also tested seven people who took high doses of saccharin for a week. Four of them showed worse blood sugar responses.

It was a fascinating finding that launched a whole field of research. But seven people for one week can't tell us what happens to everyone, and larger trials haven't shown a consistent blood sugar effect.

Story two: what long-term observational studies say

Here's the darker version.

  • A 2017 analysis looked at both kinds of evidence. The trials showed no clear effect on weight. The observational studies linked regular sweetener use with weight gain and higher rates of obesity, type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure and heart disease 8.
  • A 2019 review commissioned by the WHO found mostly low-certainty evidence, with few clear benefits or harms 9.

The plot twist: who's drinking the diet soda?

Think about who switches to diet soda. Often it's someone who's gaining weight, who's been told they have prediabetes, or whose doctor told them to cut sugar. They were already at higher risk before the first sip.

In an observational study, that can make it look like the sweetener caused the problem, when actually the problem led to the sweetener. Scientists call this reverse causation, and it's very hard to fully correct for with statistics.

That's why the trials matter so much here, even though they're shorter.

The 2023 headlines, one by one

Aspartame and cancer

Aspartame is one of the most studied food additives in history.

In 2023, the WHO's cancer agency (IARC) placed aspartame in Group 2B, "possibly carcinogenic" 16. That sounds alarming until you learn what Group 2B means: it describes how certain the evidence of a hazard is, not how big the risk is. Aloe vera extract and pickled vegetables are in the same group.

On the very same day, a separate WHO and UN expert committee reviewed aspartame and kept its safe daily limit unchanged at 40 mg per kg of body weight 16. For a 70 kg adult, that's roughly 9 to 14 cans of diet soda every day for life.

A large French study, NutriNet-Santé, did find a modestly higher cancer risk in people consuming more artificial sweeteners, especially aspartame and acesulfame-K 10. It's a well-run study, but it's observational, with the same reverse causation problems. Older rat studies reporting cancers 11 have been criticized for their methods and haven't convinced regulators.

What we don't know: Whether there's a small cancer risk at very high intakes over decades. Current evidence doesn't show a clear risk at normal intakes, but it can't completely rule out a small one.

Sucralose and DNA

A 2023 lab study tested sucralose-6-acetate, a byproduct of making sucralose that can also form in the gut, on human cells in a dish 12. At certain concentrations, it damaged DNA.

Cells in a dish lack the body's protective systems, and lab doses don't translate neatly to real life. Earlier reviews, including human studies, found no harm from sucralose at normal intakes 13. Worth following up. Not proof of harm.

Erythritol and blood clots

This is the most open question right now. A 2023 study found that people with higher blood levels of erythritol had more heart attacks and strokes, and that erythritol made platelets clot more easily in lab tests 14.

Here's the complication: your body makes erythritol too, and levels tend to be higher in people with metabolic problems. So high blood erythritol might be a marker of poor health rather than a result of eating it. The researchers also showed that eating a large dose sharply raised blood levels, which keeps the concern alive.

What we don't know: Whether erythritol in normal food amounts raises heart risk. More research is needed.

About that WHO guideline

The WHO's 2023 advice against sweeteners for weight control 15 was a conditional recommendation based on low-certainty evidence, and it doesn't apply to people with diabetes. Many researchers disagreed because it leaned on observational data more than on trials.

One fair reading: sweeteners aren't a magic tool for long-term weight loss, and water and less sweetness overall may be better goals. That's sensible advice even if the evidence of harm is uncertain.

How a sweetener gets its "safe" number

Every approved sweetener comes with an acceptable daily intake, or ADI. Regulators usually set it by finding the highest dose that caused no harm in long-term animal studies, then dividing that by 100 to build in a wide safety margin.

That's why the limits sound enormous in cans of soda. It also means going over the ADI now and then isn't a cliff edge. The margin is there for uncertainty, not because harm begins at that line.

The system isn't perfect. Animal studies can miss effects that only show up in people, which is why observational studies like NutriNet-Santé still matter, even with their flaws.

The scorecard

Question What the evidence suggests Confidence
Better than sugar for weight? Yes, modestly, in trials Moderate
Better than water? Not clearly Low
Raise blood sugar? Not meaningfully in trials Moderate
Cause cancer at normal intakes? Not shown; small risk not fully ruled out Low to moderate
Is erythritol a heart risk? Open question Low

Common questions

Are stevia and monk fruit safer because they're "natural"? "Natural" doesn't guarantee safety, and "artificial" doesn't mean harmful. Stevia has a reasonable safety record. Many stevia and monk fruit products are blended with erythritol, so check labels.

What about xylitol and other sugar alcohols? They can cause bloating or diarrhea in larger amounts. Xylitol is highly toxic to dogs, so keep it away from pets. It's also being studied for possible links to clotting.

Do sweeteners make you crave sugar? It's plausible, but trials haven't shown consistent increases in appetite or sugar intake.

Are they okay for kids? Most experts say there isn't enough long-term research to recommend them routinely for children. Water and milk are the defaults.

Do sweeteners spike insulin? In most trials, sweeteners on their own don't meaningfully raise insulin. Some studies hint at small responses in some people, but results are inconsistent.

Why do some labels warn about phenylalanine? Aspartame contains phenylalanine, which people with a rare genetic condition called phenylketonuria (PKU) must avoid. For everyone else, it's a normal part of protein.

Are diet drinks bad for teeth? They don't feed cavity-causing bacteria, but many are acidic and can still erode enamel if sipped all day.

What about allulose and other newer sweeteners? Allulose is a "rare sugar" with very few calories that doesn't raise blood sugar much. It's considered safe by US regulators, but it has much less long-term research behind it than older sweeteners.

Are sweeteners safe during pregnancy? Regulators consider approved sweeteners safe within their limits, including in pregnancy. A few observational studies have raised questions, which aren't settled. Many people choose to keep intake modest, which is a reasonable approach.

The takeaway

Fahlberg and Schlatter stumbled onto sweetness by accident. More than a century later, we're still working out exactly what it does to us.

  • If you drink sugary soda, switching to diet is very likely a step forward for weight and blood sugar.
  • Water, sparkling water and unsweetened tea or coffee are the best long-term defaults.
  • Moderate sweetener use isn't a reason for alarm based on current evidence.
  • If you eat a lot of erythritol and have heart risk factors, it's reasonable to cut back while the research continues.

And next time a sweetener headline goes viral, ask one question: was this a trial, an observational study, or cells in a dish? The answer will tell you most of what you need to know.

References

  1. Rogers PJ, et al. Does low-energy sweetener consumption affect energy intake and body weight? A systematic review, including meta-analyses, of the evidence from human and animal studies. Int J Obes. 2016;40(3):381-94. PubMed 26365102

  2. Miller PE, Perez V. Low-calorie sweeteners and body weight and composition: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and prospective cohort studies. Am J Clin Nutr. 2014;100(3):765-77. PubMed 24944060

  3. Higgins KA, Mattes RD. A randomized controlled trial contrasting the effects of 4 low-calorie sweeteners and sucrose on body weight in adults with overweight or obesity. Am J Clin Nutr. 2019;109(5):1288-1301. PubMed 30997499

  4. Peters JC, et al. The effects of water and non-nutritive sweetened beverages on weight loss and weight maintenance: a randomized clinical trial. Obesity. 2016;24(2):297-304. PubMed 26708700

  5. Nichol AD, Holle MJ, An R. Glycemic impact of non-nutritive sweeteners: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2018;72(6):796-804. PubMed 29760482

  6. Grotz VL, et al. Lack of effect of sucralose on glucose homeostasis in subjects with type 2 diabetes. J Am Diet Assoc. 2003;103(12):1607-12. PubMed 14647086

  7. Suez J, et al. Artificial sweeteners induce glucose intolerance by altering the gut microbiota. Nature. 2014;514(7521):181-6. PubMed 25231862

  8. Azad MB, et al. Nonnutritive sweeteners and cardiometabolic health: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials and prospective cohort studies. CMAJ. 2017;189(28):E929-E939. PubMed 28716847

  9. Toews I, Lohner S, Küllenberg de Gaudry D, Sommer H, Meerpohl JJ. Association between intake of non-sugar sweeteners and health outcomes: systematic review and meta-analyses of randomised and non-randomised controlled trials and observational studies. BMJ. 2019;364:k4718. PubMed 30602577

  10. Debras C, et al. Artificial sweeteners and cancer risk: results from the NutriNet-Santé population-based cohort study. PLoS Med. 2022;19(3):e1003950. PubMed 35324894

  11. Soffritti M, et al. First experimental demonstration of the multipotential carcinogenic effects of aspartame administered in the feed to Sprague-Dawley rats. Environ Health Perspect. 2006;114(3):379-85. PubMed 16507461

  12. Schiffman SS, et al. Toxicological and pharmacokinetic properties of sucralose-6-acetate and its parent sucralose: in vitro screening assays. J Toxicol Environ Health B Crit Rev. 2023;26(6):307-341. PubMed 37246822

  13. Magnuson BA, Roberts A, Nestmann ER. Critical review of the current literature on the safety of sucralose. Food Chem Toxicol. 2017;106(Pt A):324-355. PubMed 28558975

  14. Witkowski M, et al. The artificial sweetener erythritol and cardiovascular event risk. Nat Med. 2023;29(3):710-718.

  15. World Health Organization. Use of non-sugar sweeteners: WHO guideline. Geneva: WHO; 2023.

  16. IARC Monographs Programme and JECFA. Aspartame hazard and risk assessment results released. WHO news release, 14 July 2023.

This article is for general education and isn't a substitute for personalized medical advice.