‹ Longevity

Longevity

Supplements: What I Take and Why

This is my routine, not a prescription. Supplements can interact with medicines and health conditions, and quality varies between brands. Talk with your own doctor before you start anything, and look for products tested by an independent lab.

Patients often ask me, half joking, what is in my pill box. Here is the honest answer: one day of my routine, from the first pill in the morning to the last one before bed.

Some of these have solid evidence behind them. Some are educated bets. I label each one so you know which is which: Strong Promising Speculative. Each will eventually get its own page.

But first, a warning that matters more than any single supplement.

What is really in the bottle?

Supplements are not regulated like medicines. The FDA does not approve them before they are sold, and quality control varies widely from company to company. What is on the label is not always what is in the bottle.

That is not a theoretical worry. Thorne sued an Amazon seller over Thorne-labeled products that were expired, tampered with or tainted.1 NOW found 11 counterfeit versions of its own supplements sold by a single Amazon seller.2 A pill that looks right, in a bottle that looks right, may not be right. When you can, buy directly from the company or an authorized retailer.

These are the companies I like and buy from myself. It is not an endorsement, just what I use: Renue by Science for my NAD+ supplement, NOW for many everyday basics, and Thorne, which has historically had very good quality.

Morning: waking up the machine

Caffeine Strong

I take my caffeine as a pill so I know exactly how much I am getting: about 200 mg in the morning and another 200 mg around noon. Caffeine reliably improves alertness and exercise performance. The FDA notes that up to about 400 mg a day is generally not linked to harmful effects in healthy adults. People who are pregnant, sensitive to caffeine, anxious or prone to heart rhythm problems should take less, and caffeine late in the day can quietly ruin your sleep.

L-theanine Promising

Caffeine has a partner. L-theanine is an amino acid found in tea, and I take it alongside my caffeine. Small studies suggest the pair gives smoother focus with fewer jitters than caffeine alone, which may be part of why a cup of tea feels so different from a cup of coffee.

Taurine Promising

Taurine is an amino acid found in meat and fish, and in 2023 it had a moment. A study in Science found that taurine levels fall with age, and that taurine supplements extended life in mice and worms and improved several health markers in monkeys. That is an exciting clue. We do not yet have trials showing that it helps people live longer.

Vitamin D and K2 Promising

Vitamin D supports bone and muscle, which matters a great deal to an orthopedic surgeon, and many people are low in it. In the large VITAL trial, vitamin D did not lower cancer or heart disease overall, but it was linked to fewer autoimmune diseases. Vitamin K2 helps direct calcium into bone; the evidence for taking it is more limited. A simple blood test can tell you whether you need vitamin D.

A multivitamin, a couple of times a week Promising

I treat this as a safety net, not a foundation. In the COSMOS trials, a daily multivitamin gave older adults a small benefit on memory tests.

An NAD+ blend Speculative

This is the one people ask about most. NAD+ is a molecule cells need to make energy and repair DNA, and levels fall with age. The product I take combines NAD+ itself with two of its building blocks, NMN and NR.

Here is what the marketing will not tell you. Many products contain one, two or all three, and so far no study has shown that one is better than another. Some companies wrap them in liposomes, tiny fat bubbles meant to protect them from being broken down in the gut. That may help absorption, but some of it may also be marketing. These supplements do raise NAD+ levels in people. Clear benefits for health or lifespan have not yet been shown in human trials. I take it as an educated bet, and I want you to know that is what it is.

Urolithin A Promising

This one has an interesting backstory. Some gut bacteria make urolithin A from foods such as pomegranate, berries and walnuts, but many people's bacteria make little of it. It helps cells clear out worn-out mitochondria, the cell's power plants, so newer ones can take their place. Small human trials have shown improvements in muscle endurance.

Evening: winding down

Glycine Promising

Glycine is an amino acid that I take to help me fall asleep. In small studies, about 3 grams before bed led to better sleep quality and less tiredness the next day.

Magnesium glycinate Promising

Magnesium is involved in muscle and nerve function and in sleep. The glycinate form tends to be gentle on the stomach. The evidence that it improves sleep is modest. People with kidney disease should ask their doctor first.

Sulforaphane Promising

Sulforaphane comes from broccoli, and especially from broccoli sprouts. It switches on the body's own antioxidant and detox defenses, known as the Nrf2 pathway. Rather than adding an antioxidant from outside, it tells your cells to make more of their own. Human studies are early but encouraging.

NAC, sometimes with glycine Speculative

Some nights I add NAC to my glycine. Together they are building blocks of glutathione, one of the body's main antioxidants, which falls with age. In small trials of the pair, sometimes called GlyNAC, older adults improved on several markers of aging. Larger studies are needed.

Now and then

Ashwagandha Promising

An herb used for stress. Trials suggest it can lower stress scores and cortisol, and I do feel it helps. So why did I stop taking it regularly? It sometimes made me wake up groggy. That is a good reminder that how you respond is personal. Rare liver injury has been reported, and it is not recommended in pregnancy.

Melatonin when I travel Strong

Jet lag is your body clock stuck in the wrong time zone. Melatonin taken near the new bedtime helps reset it, and a Cochrane review found it effective for jet lag in most people.

What I skip

Collagen, for muscle

Collagen powder is everywhere, and it is a protein, so it seems like it should build muscle. It does not do that well. Collagen is missing an essential amino acid entirely and is low in several others. In a 10-week training study, people who took whey after workouts built more muscle than people who took collagen.3 Collagen may still have a role for tendons and other connective tissue, which interests me as an orthopedic surgeon, but that is unproven. Speculative For muscle, regular protein wins.

Recovery extracts

Tart cherry and pomegranate extracts can speed recovery after an unusually hard or new workout. But in a study of about 10 weeks of training, taking a protein-and-fruit-extract supplement every day gave an early boost that disappeared by the end: no more strength or muscle than placebo.4 For everyday training, I would rather eat the fruit. See my superfoods.

See also: superfoods, peptides and the longevity overview.

References

  1. Summerville supplements maker accuses Amazon retailer of selling tainted products. The Post and Courier. 2021.

  2. Counterfeit supplements. ConsumerLab.

  3. Jacinto JL, Nunes JP, Gorissen SHM, et al. Whey protein supplementation is superior to leucine-matched collagen peptides to increase muscle thickness during a 10-week resistance training program in untrained young adults. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab. 2022.

  4. Pavis GF, Jameson TSO, Blackwell JR, et al. Daily protein-polyphenol ingestion increases daily myofibrillar protein synthesis rates and promotes early muscle functional gains during resistance training. Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab. 2022.

This page describes one doctor's personal routine for general education. It is not medical advice or a recommendation to take any supplement.